- The Knowledge
- Posts
- An arrest that shames America
An arrest that shames America
đ˝ď¸ Funny faces | Cummings â¤ď¸ Farage | âď¸ Leggers
In the headlines
Donald Trump will speak to Vladimir Putin tomorrow about a ceasefire deal in Ukraine. The US president told reporters on Air Force One that the two leaders would discuss âdividing up certain assetsâ between Moscow and Kyiv, including land and power plants. Keir Starmer says Britain is willing to deploy thousands of peacekeeping troops for âas long as it takesâ to deter another invasion. The government is facing a growing revolt from senior Labour figures over plans to save ÂŁ5bn by cutting disability benefits. Greater Manchester Mayor Andy Burnham says âthere is no case in any scenario for cutting the support available to disabled peopleâ, while veteran left-winger Diane Abbott says cuts are ânot a Labour thing to doâ. The reforms are due to be set out in full tomorrow. Parts of England could be warmer than Ibiza and Corfu this week. On the first official day of spring â Thursdayâs vernal equinox â temperatures are forecast to reach 19C in the southeast. So thatâs something.
Comment

Mahmoud Khalil at Columbia last summer. Selcuk Acar/Getty
An arrest that shames America
You may have missed it, what with everything else going on, says Andrew Sullivan on Substack, but Donald Trump is tearing apart Americaâs constitutional right to free speech. Last weekend, a prominent pro-Palestinian campus activist at Columbia University called Mahmoud Khalil was arrested by Department of Homeland Security agents as he arrived home from dinner. The 30-year-old, a green card holder, hasnât been accused of a crime. But the Trump administration has decided that his âpro-Palestinian activityâ is reason enough to kick him out of the country. He was immediately transported to a notorious jail in Louisiana, a state where âa more pliant judge is likelierâ. The White House, disgustingly, mocked him on X with a Jewish term for goodbye: âSHALOM, MAHMOUD.â
Trump has said this is âthe first arrest of manyâ. The legal rationale for Khalilâs deportation is that his pro-Palestinian activities could have âpotentially serious adverse foreign policy consequences for the USâ â an astonishingly broad interpretation that could apply to almost anything. (If the law under which he was arrested sounds McCarthyite, thatâs because it is â it was passed in 1952 to collar Holocaust survivors suspected of communist sympathies.) The government has already launched a massive AI-assisted programme called âCatch and Revokeâ, which scans everything written online to âflush outâ non-citizens deemed wrong âuns. What a disgrace all this is. It was only a month ago that JD Vance was lecturing Europeans about the decline of free speech. You donât have to support Hamas, or even think Khalil is a good egg, to see his treatment as âan outrage in a free countryâ. And letâs see if all those âbraveâ conservative defenders of free speech are condemning this. âIf they arenât, never take them seriously on this subject again.â
Quirk of history

Reply