Changing leader won’t help Labour

⚰️ Armoured coffin | 🧦 iPhone Pocket | 📸 Portrait prize

In the headlines

Home Secretary Shabana Mahmood is unveiling her sweeping asylum reforms this afternoon. The changes will include UK visa bans for countries such as Angola, Namibia and the Democratic Republic of Congo if their governments don’t start taking back illegal migrants; making refugee status temporary, with regular reviews to see if the applicant’s home country is safe for them to be returned; and allowing rejected asylum seekers only one appeal in the courts. Donald Trump has urged Republicans in Congress to vote for the release of the so-called Epstein files, in a sharp reversal of his previous position. Posting on social media ahead of tomorrow’s planned vote in the House, the US president said he had “nothing to hide”. A re-run of a landmark study which found that men have an unfair advantage in scientific careers has found the opposite is now true. In 2012, when science professors were sent identical CVs from either “John” or “Jennifer”, “John” was routinely deemed more hireable; in the new research, “Jennifer” came out on top.

Comment

Starmer and Streeting: does it matter who’s in charge? Leon Neal/Getty

Changing leader won’t help Labour

It’s easy to make the case for deposing Keir Starmer, says Fraser Nelson in The Times. He’s “a victim of his own bungling”, and Wes Streeting, the favourite to succeed him, “radiates the qualities” the PM lacks. But unlike the Tories, “for whom regicide is a form of relaxation”, Labour has always been reluctant to depose a bad leader. Besides, a change in leadership seldom works. Anyone installed after a “putsch” lacks the authority provided by an election win: cabinet rifts are harder to control; backbenchers harder to tame. And whoever’s in charge would face the same problem that has ensnared Starmer: “a structural inability to govern”.

Part of the issue is that the state has “grown out of all proportion to its usefulness” – the UK government spends twice what it did when Tony Blair entered No 10. But the bigger problem is the inability to change the system. Governments used to be held back by trade unions; “now, it’s lawyers”. The mountain of regulations and laws that need adhering to means pretty much any state project can be halted or delayed by activists seeking judicial reviews. This clogs everything up, from increasing our energy capacity to building more houses. Starmer thought the government’s “sclerosis” was down to Tory incompetence but he has instead discovered that “the system genuinely doesn’t work”. As long as that remains the case, it won’t matter who’s in charge. “Starmer or Streeting; Labour or Tory.” They’ll make as little progress as Reform UK has managed at the local authorities under its control. Unless Labour can find a way to reclaim power from the regulators and the courts, “no reshuffle or reboot or replacement will be able to save it”.

Advertisement

The forthcoming Autumn Statement is widely anticipated as the most challenging and potentially controversial Budget for decades. We thought some expert analysis on the contents would be helpful for your financial planning.

Join me for an exclusive online session where I take a first look at the Budget with Charlotte Ransom, CEO, and Gerard Lyons, Chief Economic Strategist - both from Netwealth, one of the UK’s most innovative and successful wealth management firms. They will provide initial thoughts, breaking down the key announcements and exploring their potential impact on markets, taxation and, most importantly, your savings and investments.

Photography

Winning images of the Taylor Wessing Photo Portrait Prize, which are currently being exhibited at the National Portrait Gallery, include a young Inuit girl in northwest Greenland after taking part in an ancient seal hunting ritual; tangled contortionists in Mongolia; cousins in Pentecostal dress following Sunday service in London; a leopard print-clad woman in Naples; and an all-female Morris dancing troupe in Gloucestershire. To see more, click on the image.

Thank you

A huge thank you to the many readers who took out a paid subscription over the weekend. We’re blown away by your support.

If you can afford it, can we tempt you to join them? The Knowledge really is exceptional value: only £4 a month or £40 for the first year, which works out at just 80p a week. Eighty pence!

In the rest of today’s newsletter, for example, you’ll get to enjoy pieces on:

😡 Growing discontent in China
📱 The Apple kit that looks like Borat’s mankini
🚑 A robo-ambulance in Ukraine
🤭 What the next Starmer book should be called
🎓 Grade inflation at Harvard
🇰🇵 The power behind the throne in North Korea
💬 Nora Ephron on relationships

Let us know what you thought of today’s issue by replying to this email
To find out about advertising and partnerships, click here 
Been forwarded this newsletter? Try it for free 
Enjoying The Knowledge? Click to share

Reply

or to participate.