- The Knowledge
- Posts
- The reason New Yorkers went for Mamdani
The reason New Yorkers went for Mamdani
đ Pricey pizza | đŹ Office Traitors | đ» Kimâs merkin
In the headlines
Justice Secretary David Lammy is under mounting pressure after two more prisoners were mistakenly released from jail. Ibrahim Kaddour-Cherif, a 24-year-old convicted sex offender from Algeria, was freed in error last Wednesday, but the prison service only told the police earlier this week and he remains at large. William Smith, who was accidentally released after being convicted for fraud on Monday, handed himself in this morning. Electric vehicle drivers are likely to be hit with a new âpay-per-mileâ tax in the forthcoming budget, amounting to an extra ÂŁ250 a year on average. The scheme, which would charge EV motorists 3p per mile on top of other road taxes, comes amid falling fuel duty revenue as more people switch from petrol to electric. The Collins Dictionary word of the year is âvibe codingâ, which means making an app or website by describing it to AI rather than writing the code manually. Others on the list include âaura farmingâ (cultivating a cool, charismatic persona), âbroligarchyâ (uber-rich tech bros) and âHenryâ (an acronym for âhigh earner, not rich yetâ).
Comment

Mamdani and his wife, Rama, celebrating on Tuesday. Angela Weiss/AFP/Getty
The reason New Yorkers went for Mamdani
On paper, says Gerard Baker in The Wall Street Journal, Zohran Mamdani is the kind of Democrat who might have been âinvented in a laboratory of perverted social science by a MAGA Dr Frankensteinâ. New Yorkâs mayor-elect is a socialist, an immigrant, a Muslim, the son of a film director and a professor of postcolonialism, and the holder of a degree in âAfricana studiesâ. And the 34-year-old has done plenty to make himself an enticing target for his political opponents, saying at various times he wanted to âdefund the policeâ, âglobalise the intifadaâ, open city-run grocery stores and reinvent an America in which there are no billionaires. He is a self-described child of privilege who says he would arrest the Israeli prime minister if he visited the city with the worldâs largest Jewish population.
Plenty of Mamdaniâs policies are, predictably enough, laughable. Freezing rents (which has been tried before) would only âaggravate the housing supply problemâ, and raising the taxes needed to fund âfreeâ childcare and buses will drive out many who already shoulder the greatest tax burden. But hereâs the thing: Mamdani is a âculture warrior of impeccable and deplorable standingâ, but thatâs not why he won. He won because he spoke directly to votersâ concerns that their lives have become unaffordable in a city where what were once basic aspirations â a decent job, a home â have become âunrealisable fantasiesâ. If you want to live in New York these days, and you donât have rich parents or a job at an investment bank, tech company or law firm, âyou can dream onâ. Mamdaniâs radicalism wonât restore the good times. But his success is a reminder that the âsteady vanishing of opportunityâ is coming to define politics everywhere.
đłïžđ This is also, clearly, a vote against Donald Trump, says Jamelle Bouie in The New York Times. As were the other big election results on Tuesday, for governor of Virginia and New Jersey, where Democrats delivered similarly âcrushing defeatsâ to their Republican opponents. This is the first major round of elections since Trump returned to the White House, and although voters in each place had their own local concerns, there is no doubt this was a chance to âregister their discontentâ with Washington. Itâs sometimes forgotten amid the bluster, but Trumpâs approval ratings are at a second-term low of 37%. For his party, the phenomenally effective vote-winner has become an âalbatrossâ.
Food and drink
More than a century after a baker in Naples supposedly served up the first pizza to Queen Margherita of Savoy â who enjoyed the dish so much it was named in her honour â fancy pizzas are âback on the menuâ, says Leonora Field-Foster in The Times. In London they include the ÂŁ26 swirly pizzetta au chocolat Jivara, decorated with Valrhona Jivara chocolate and caramelised Piedmont hazelnuts, at Mayfairâs Bagatelle; a ÂŁ60 option at Alba in Knightsbridge made with fior di latte, scrambled egg and black caviar; and the ÂŁ30 pizza topped with lobster, roasted datterini tomatoes, gremolata and sea vegetables at Tozi, in Battersea Power Station. For more posh pies, click the image.
Quirk of language
The infuriating and stupid public transport slogan âSee it, Say it, Sortedâ is far better in Latin, says Ysenda Maxtone Graham in The Oldie. Translated with the correct grammar, imperatives and participle, it comes out as the wonderfully appropriate: Vide, Dic, Rectum.
TV

The Traitors presenter Claudia Winkleman. BBC
My office organised its own weeks-long version of The Traitors, says Ed Campbell in The Guardian. âI almost lost my mind.â I was one of the anointed âTraitorsâ, so had to spend every moment of every day lying to âFaithfulâ colleagues: as I warmed up my lunch in the microwave; at work drinks; to my manager. During a three-way interrogation between me and two Faithfuls, one of them told me: âYouâd have to be some sort of psychopath to be able to lie like that.â I spoke about nothing else, even at home, and found myself dreaming about it. About a month after the game ended I had to take some time off work for stress. Pretty sure it wasnât a coincidence.
Comment

Starmer with Margaret Aspinall at the Labour conference. Oli Scarff/AFP/Getty
How victims came to rule Britain
British politics is increasingly ruled by one group in particular, says Bagehot in The Economist: victims. In the past five years, âvictimsâ have been mentioned in parliament 16,515 times, more than âBrexitâ (10,797 times), âwelfareâ (9,978) and âimmigrationâ (8,644). They received 24 shout-outs in Labourâs recent manifesto, compared to just two for âpensionersâ; at the partyâs annual conference in Liverpool, Keir Starmer was introduced on stage by Margaret Aspinall, whose son died at Hillsborough. âThis party was founded to hear working-class people like that,â the PM said. âTo look directly into the eyes of their suffering.â Labour once worked to advance the economic interests of its members. âNow it manages their emotional needs.â
The problem with politics built around victims is that it leads to bad policy. Victims terrify politicians â âthey are apex stakeholdersâ â so normal rules for decision-making, on risk, cost, proportionality and so on, get thrown out. The result is legislation like âMartynâs lawâ, named after a victim of the 2017 Manchester Arena bombing, which requires any venue that can hold more than 200 people to have an anti-terror plan, âeven if it is a village hallâ. Government inquiries have become âsprawling affairsâ with victims involved at every step â by the time they are finished, those responsible have typically left office and any recommendations are dangerously late. Westminsterâs victim culture also ignores the fact that state failures are âcollective scandalsâ: Hillsborough could have happened at another stadium; Grenfell wasnât the only tower clad in flammable material. âWhat should be societyâs problem becomes an individual one.â This is not healthy. We are becoming an âautocracy of lived experienceâ, where âpoliticians advise and victims decideâ.
Life

Hopkins with Joan Allen in Nixon (1995)
When Anthony Hopkins was playing Richard Nixon in Oliver Stoneâs eponymous 1995 biopic, says Ed Power in The Daily Telegraph, his co-star Paul Sorvino took him aside and told him he was making a hash of the part. âYour voice was all wrong,â said Sorvino. âYour speech patterns are way off.â Hopkins, despite being an Oscar winner, took this critique to heart and told Stone to fire him, saying he didnât want to ruin the film. Stone immediately guessed what had happened. âHas that fat slob been getting to you?â he asked. âYou donât have to answer. I know he has. Heâs a baby. Donât take any notice of him.â
Inside politics
Rachel Reevesâs justification for tax rises is âalmost identicalâ to that of Denis Healey half a century ago, says Simon Walters in The Independent. The then Labour chancellor increased the basic rate of income tax by 2p after failing to slash public spending and caving to demands for large public sector pay rises. So itâs perhaps worth Reeves considering how this turned out: things continued to go rapidly downhill, the government had to âbeg the International Monetary Fund to bail out Britainâ, and Healey ended up belatedly imposing the enormous cuts he had foolishly tried to avoid.
Snapshot

Snapshot answer
Theyâre merkins, says Flora Gill in Air Mail, âKim Kardashian styleâ. Specifically, theyâre three variations of the âFaux Hair Micro String Thongâ â made by Kardashianâs $4bn underwear company Skims, which produced a viral ânipple braâ a few years ago â in âClay Gingerâ, âSienna Black Curlyâ and âCocoa Brownâ. At just ÂŁ34, the pubic wigs are surprisingly cheap, though I suppose you have to factor in the cost of regular waxes too. âIâm pretty sure to have the full effect youâd have to remove your real hair before applying Kardashianâs.â
Quoted
âMost of us spend too much time on the last 24 hours and too little on the last 6,000 years.â
American historian Will Durant
Thatâs it. Youâre done.
Let us know what you thought of todayâs issue by replying to this email
To find out about advertising and partnerships, click here
Been forwarded this newsletter? Try it for free
Enjoying The Knowledge? Click to share



Reply